Trending Pottery Barn Halloween Look for LESS (But Hurry, They Could Sell Out Before Summer’s Over!)

Shop our top picks for Pottery Barn Halloween alternatives!

Creep it real… (real budget-friendly) with these Pottery Barn Halloween alternatives we found! These trendy, festive decor pieces are to die for. 👻

Pottery Barn’s Halloween decor is undeniably fantastic every single year. Think cozy, yet spooky vibes, with a dash of sophisticated witchiness. 👻 But guess what? We found equally bewitching alternatives that won’t haunt your wallet!

Keep reading to see how and where you can snag these stylish, spooky finds without the sticker scaries. 🤩

1. This adorable ghost pillow is under $20 on Amazon.

We’re pretty sure no one could turn down this adorable lookalike! It’s hard to believe the Pottery Barn one is a best seller, sitting at almost $90, when you can grab an identical lookalike for over $65 less!

Are you a Costco member? 

We spotted this adorable ghost pillow at Costco for their 2025 Halloween collection! While it’s currently not available online, you can grab it in store while supplies last for just $10.99! Fingers crossed it makes it’s way online soon!

2. Hang spooky floating candles from your ceiling (and save over $130 on Amazon).

Not only will you save over $100 by opting to buy our team-tested Amazon floating candles, but you’ll also get 2 more candles over the Pottery Barn option! These battery-operated candles come equipped with 4.9 feet of fishing line pre-attached so they are ready to be hung anywhere in your home. The best part? You also get a magic wand remote that can switch these hanging candles on and off from a distance.

We shared these Amazon floating candles in action on Instagram last year!

3. These lit ghosts will look spooktacular on your porch, and you’ll save well over half the cost.

Floating sheet ghosts are a classic, charming Halloween decoration that have surged in popularity this year! They’re going viral on social right now, with lots of people opting for Amazon ghost kits over the pricier Pottery Barn option. Be sure to order yours soon if interested, as they have been selling out.

4. Decorated with reusable terracotta pumpkins. 

These adorable terracotta jack-o-lanterns are a timeless Halloween decor you’ll love getting out year after year. Plus, we love the World Market one more because it’s over $59 LESS and has a more realistic stem.

Just note that there currently aren’t any reviews since this item is a new seasonal item, so consider checking it out in-store before buying if you have any hesitations.

Love the look of Pottery Barn’s black terracotta pumpkins?

World Market also has some smoother-looking Terracotta Jack O’ Lanterns, and paired with some Rust-oleum black stone spray paint, we think they’ll make the perfect lookalike for a fraction of the cost!

5. Grab a cozy sherpa pumpkin pillow for your living room. 

What’s better than a sherpa blanket? A sherpa pumpkin-shaped pillow, hands down. What’s even better? Spending half the amount of cash on it! This cute and festive pillow will be something you’ll want to keep out all season long!

6. Make your own charcuterie board with our easy DIY for half the cost.

Last year, our Hip Sidekick, Lina, made this adorable skeleton charcuterie board. It was a play on this nearly $100 Pottery Barn charcuterie board, and we couldn’t love the results more! Head over to her full DIY skeleton Halloween charcuterie board to find out how you can make this affordable and festive piece before your spooky party! Plus, if you already have a food-grade stain and glue, this DIY could potentially be under $30!

7. Use a skeleton serving tray and save over $100 at TJ Maxx. 

While clearly not an identical lookalike, we couldn’t resist sharing this skeleton serving board. The materials are still reminiscent of something you’d buy at Pottery Barn, with the marble slab for serving party food and the lanky skeletons holding it up. All in all, it’s the perfect spooky decor to elevate a tablescape while staying on a realistic budget!

We’ve already spotted plenty of Halloween goodies for this year!