Easy 3-Ingredient Yogurt Cream Pie (Try Collin’s Favorite Childhood Dessert!)
This yogurt cream pie is a cinch to make using just a few ingredients!
This is the easiest fruit pie you can make!
I’m excited to share a special dessert recipe that is very dear to Collin’s heart and tastes incredible! Now having made it myself, I can confirm that this yogurt cream pie is a perfect, easy treat to make at home with the family. It takes just a few inexpensive ingredients and about 5 minutes to prepare. Yes, really!
The result is a luscious and creamy pie that is sweet and yet so very refreshing! It’s a perfect way to use up the last of the summer berries and tastes fancy with minimal effort! I am now a huge fan of this idea, and I think you will be, too!
Here’s why Collin loves this easy yogurt pie:
“Oh my…this pie brings me back to my childhood! My mom was not a fan of cooking but she did always come through with her yogurt cream pie. 😋 This was my absolute favorite dessert growing up and little did I know when I was young how incredibly easy it is to make and that you basically need just 3 main ingredients – yogurt, Cool Whip, and a delicious, pre-made graham cracker crust. If you’ve not tried this pie yet, MAKE IT!”
Strawberry Yogurt Pie
yield: 8 SERVINGS
prep time: 5 MINUTES
total time: 5 MINUTES
Creamy cloud-like strawberry yogurt frozen pie.
Ingredients
Directions
1
Mix the yogurt and whipped topping together in a bowl. Add in fresh berries, if desired.
2
Transfer the filling to the graham cracker crust, and spread evenly. Freeze for at least 2 hours or overnight.
3
Set on the counter for 20 minutes or so to defrost a bit and cut the pie. Add additional whipped cream and berries if desired. Enjoy!
Tips for making the BEST easy yogurt cream pie:
- Use a brand or style of yogurt that your family loves! We love Greek yogurt for its creaminess, but it certainly doesn’t have to be what you use. This could also be done with various fruit flavors like blueberry, raspberry, or even orange would be delicious! Lemon yogurt with fresh blueberries would be awesome, too.
- Let’s talk whipped topping. You can use your favorite brand, such as Cool Whip. Whipped topping just makes the texture super light, fluffy, and cloudlike!
- This pie takes about 5 minutes to make, but be sure to account for the time it takes to freeze it. This is a great dessert idea to compile early in the day and have after dinner. Or you can freeze it overnight, and then leave it on the counter to soften a bit before serving.
- The fresh berries in the pie filling are optional, but honestly, it is so yummy. You can serve it with whipped cream on top and additional berries if desired. I like to use my handy immersion blender and heavy whipping cream to make whipped cream quickly for serving pies.
The verdict is in…this easy yogurt cream pie is delish and so refreshing!
I am pretty sure whipped topping and yogurt are the best combo ever for a creamy pie. Honestly, it was hard not to lick the entire bowl clean when making this, and I have no regrets about the tastes I did sneak. 😄
I love this simple idea, and my family went crazy over it, too. I can’t wait to try some other flavors in the future!
Ooh sounds so yummy! And the perfect dessert for this hot humid summer. Thanks!
YES Lori! Super refreshing <3
Calories, please?
Carb Manager is a great free resource – 190 calories per slice
My husband loves this. I use half of the whipped topping in the mix and also stir in a packet of instant pudding mix – white chocolate is fantastic in this. Then I put the other half of the topping on top of the pie. The pudding mix makes it firm enough that it doesn’t have to be frozen just chilled. this is a great dessert for diabetics because everything can be sugar free/ fat free.
Thanks Darla! Great ideas!
Will have to try this! Sounds yummy!!
YES! It’s very easy and yum.
A desert I can make and eat while kids are in school……Er… I mean to have READY for kids after school! lol
Yep! And you can lick the spoon without sharing! HA
I wonder if this will work with oat or soy yogurt?
Yes I would imagine so!
I think I’m gonna give this a go! Truwhip in green tub (non-dairy) is yummy too!
Awesome! Thanks Chris – enjoy!
Trying a blackberry version tonight.
I used to make this pie years ago, but I remember using liquid jello with it. the jello flavor matched with the yogurt flavor. It was very refreshing!
Oh yum!
This looks yummy but what could I use for the crust?. I do the keto diet. Or maybe just make it without the crust.
You could use this crust from this Keto Recipe.
I actually made a keto version for our site Hip2Keto.com. Stay tuned in the coming weeks for that post. I made a crust from butter and crushed keto cookies and pressed mixture in a pie pan and baked for 15 minutes. You can also google almond flour pie crust recipes. 👍
I’ve made a similar recipe using crushed nuts for the crust and it worked pretty well.
Made this last weekend. We loved it. Thanks for sharing it
Ohhh yay! Thay makes me so happy. Thanks for sharing!
Thanks for this recipe. Simple is about all I can do theses days. Looks like a winner to me!
Thanks Sharon! You will love this 🙌💕 It’s so good!
Thinking of trying this with honey Greek yogurt and fresh blueberries. I hove a surplus of them 😊
Oh yum! Enjoy 💕😍👏
We had this growing up too! So good!
YES! It’s simple, but so yummy! 😋🙌💕
Do you think it could work with homemade whipped cream vs whipped topping?
yes! that would be great too!
This is my daughter’s favorite! I actually make it using the mini graham cracker pie crusts instead of the big pie crust. They come with 6 in a pack, and I just put them all in our freezer. They’re easier to handle for a kid, than taking a giant pie out each time and then I don’t have to help her cut it or anything. I like it better just in the fridge, instead of the freezer though. These don’t last long around here!
Oh nice idea on the mini crusts! Thanks Jessica!
My husband grew up with these. I learned from his mom and they are my go to easy dessert especially during the summer. Great for potlucks Too.
So sweet that your husband grew up with these! 💕 They really are the perfect go-to dessert, especially for summer! 🥧☀️ Thanks for sharing!
going to have to try this but coconut based version 🙂
Sounds delicious, Amy. Enjoy! 🥥🤗